5 US Islands You’ve (Probably) Never Visited—but Should

Not all islands come with palm trees and piña coladas. While the sun-soaked slices of paradise scattered across the Caribbean may be the classic ideal, I’m drawn to quieter islands that offer something more than swim-up bars and steel-drum soundtracks.

Whether it’s slowly climbing a historic lighthouse on St. Simons Island in Georgia, scanning the waters for whales off Orcas Island in Washington, or feasting on a traditional lobster bake on Mount Desert Island in Maine, I’ve found awe in American islands that fly under the radar—yet offer something deeper.

These are a few of my favorite domestic island escapes that offer welcoming communities paired with landscapes that inspire a slower rhythm of life.

The Golden Isles

Georgia

Time doesn’t just slow down on the Golden Isles; it practically stretches out and settles in, inviting you to do the same. Just north of Jacksonville, this sweep of barrier islands showcases the South at its most raw and picturesque: moss-draped oaks, wide beaches perfect for sunset strolls, historic landmarks, and a quiet rhythm that encourages truly savoring that glass of sweet tea.

One of the most beloved spots is St. Simons Island, where climbing the 129 steps of its historic lighthouse rewards with sweeping views of the Atlantic. Below, charming mom-and-pop shops and shaded lanes radiate charm, and Southern hospitality is more than just a phrase; it’s woven into the fabric of life.

For something more secluded, ferry to Little St. Simons Island, a privately protected wilderness with 11,000 acres and seven miles of empty beach. It’s an unspoiled haven where kayakers and birders can spend hours in the symphony of wind, waves, and rustling marsh grass.

San Juan Islands

Washington

Despite their growing popularity, the San Juan Islands still offer a peaceful slice of the Pacific Northwest just 90 minutes north of Seattle. Board a Washington State Ferry from Anacortes for a scenic ride past some of the 172 islands and reefs that make up the archipelago. Two standout destinations, Orcas Island andLopez Island offer distinct personalities and experiences.

Orcas Island feels like a fairytale brought to life. Shaded trails wind beneath fragrant pine forests, opening up to sweeping ocean vistas—especially if you make the climb to the top of Mount Constitution in Moran State Park, the highest point in the islands. In town, you’ll find eclectic galleries and local art shops that echo the island’s creative spirit. Don’t miss a whale-watching trip, as wild orcas—the island’s namesake—appear year-round.

On Lopez Island, nicknamed “Slo-pez” for its relaxed vibe, the pace is slower still. Expect friendly waves from locals, farm stands on the honor system, and quiet roads perfect for biking or strolling.

Pine Island

Florida

The Sunshine State has no shortage of islands and inlets boasting white-sand beaches, sprawling resorts, upscale shops, and sunburned tourists. Pine Island, however, has managed to hold onto its Old Florida fishing village roots. There are no stoplights, no high-rises, and no chain restaurants on this quiet island, just 30 minutes west of Fort Myers.

The largest island on Florida’s Gulf Coast, Pine Island offers a more laid-back, hometown feel, with fishing and agriculture (especially fruit and palm farms) still central to daily life. Wander Matlacha, a tiny fishing village turned colorful artist enclave, known for its vibrant murals, mom-and-pop eateries, and local art galleries. And while Pine Island itself has no traditional sandy beaches, it’s a peaceful base for catching ferries to the unspoiled shores of Cayo Costa, North Captiva, or Cabbage Key—ideal for travelers who want Florida vibes without all the flash.

Apostle Islands

Wisconsin

The Apostle Islands are perhaps best known for their striking visuals: towering sandstone cliffs and stunning sea caves. Many who journey to this archipelago of 21 islands on Lake Superior in the northwestern corner of Wisconsin explore the landscape by water. Kayaking, sailing, and fishing are top draws, but the sandy beaches, scenic overlooks, and quiet coves invite relaxation without effort.

Base yourself on Madeline Island, the largest of the islands, and island-hop to visit some of the six historic lighthouses scattered across the Apostle Islands National Lakeshore. It’s the largest and most complete collection of historic lighthouses in the National Park System. Also make time to explore the enduring cultural connection to the Ojibwe people, who have lived in and stewarded this region for thousands of years. Delving into the history of the island at the Madeline Island Museum or timing your trip with a public powwow can bring this cultural legacy to life.

Mount Desert Island

Maine

Maine is full of island charm, but Mount Desert Island stands apart as the gateway to one of America’s most treasured landscapes: Acadia National Park. While most day-trippers stick to the area immediately surrounding Bar Harbor, a postcard-perfect town with souvenir shops, ice cream parlors, and an expansive greenspace overlooking the bay, those who venture beyond the crowds are rewarded with a deeper sense of island life.

My family rented a house and a car, giving us freedom to explore the quieter corners of the 108-square-mile island, venturing to spots such as Southwest Harbor and Seal Cove, where lobster boats seem to outnumber tourists and locals welcomed us with warm conversation and fresh-caught seafood. Don’t leave without tasting some of the best lobster you’ll ever eat—from a no-frills, roadside shack such as The Travelin’ Lobster or at a scenic waterfront dining spot such as Abel’s Lobster.

…..

These five islands offer just a glimpse of the many peaceful escapes waiting to welcome you right here in the US. You’re bound to be surprised by the hidden gems that beckon just beyond your backyard.