Your Comprehensive Guide to Picking the Best Rewards Credit Card

Unlocking the power of rewards cards starts with understanding your spending habits and the financial benefits you value most

woman holding phone and credit card
AAA The Extra Mile Background Shape
September 12, 2024·4 min read

Navigating the vast landscape of rewards credit cards can be overwhelming. From travel perks to cash-back incentives, the card choices seem endless. Understanding your spending habits financial goals can help you find a rewards card to fit your lifestyle. In this guide, we'll walk you through the essential considerations to help you choose the best rewards card for you.

using credit card for online shopping

Understanding rewards credit cards

Rewards credit cards offer benefits such as cash back, travel points, miles, or other incentives based on your spending.

  • Types of Rewards: Identify your spending patterns—whether you spend more on groceries, travel, dining, or gas—to choose a card that maximizes rewards in those categories.
  • Sign-Up Bonuses: Many cards offer attractive sign-up bonuses, typically in the form of cash back or points after meeting a spending threshold within the first few months of card ownership.
  • Annual Fee vs. No Annual Fee: Evaluate whether the rewards and benefits outweigh the annual fee, which can run upwards of $700 with certain high-end cards. Some cards waive the fee for the first year, allowing you to try out the benefits before committing long-term.

Matching rewards to your lifestyle

Consider how you plan to use your rewards, and consider a card that caters to your spending habits.

  • Travel Rewards: If you frequently travel, consider cards that offer travel points or miles, along with perks such as airline lounge access, priority boarding, and travel insurance.
  • Cash-Back Rewards: For those who prefer cash rewards, cash-back cards offer a percentage back on every purchase, which can add up significantly over time.
  • Specialty Rewards: Some cards cater to specific interests like dining, entertainment, or even pet expenses, offering higher rewards in these categories.

couple at hotel pool

Evaluating redemption options

Earning rewards is one thing; redeeming them is quite another thing. Be sure to consider the flexibility of redemption options.

  • Statement Credits: Easily apply cash-back rewards directly to your credit card statement, reducing your balance or future payments.
  • Travel Redemptions: Use travel points or miles for flights, hotel stays, rental cars, or even experiences like tours and activities.
  • Gift Cards and Merchandise: Some cards allow you to redeem rewards for gift cards at popular retailers or for merchandise from their rewards catalog.

Additional benefits and protections

Beyond rewards, premium credit cards with higher annual fees and credit requirements often include valuable perks that enhance your cardholder experience.

  • Purchase Protection: Covers your eligible purchases against damage or theft for a specified period.
  • Extended Warranty: Extends the manufacturer's warranty on eligible purchases made with the card.
  • Travel Insurance: Includes trip cancellation/interruption insurance, baggage delay coverage, and emergency assistance services.
  • Concierge Services: Provides access to a dedicated concierge for booking travel, dining reservations, and other lifestyle services.

0% APR promotion

Financial considerations

When shopping for a rewards card, don’t let the rewards distract you from the other financial factors of the card.

  • Interest Rates: Pay attention to the APR (Annual Percentage Rate), especially if you carry a balance, as interest charges can offset rewards benefits.
  • Credit Score Impact: Applying for multiple credit cards within a short period can temporarily lower your credit score. Monitor your credit utilization and payment history.
  • Introductory APR Offers: Some cards offer 0% APR for a limited time on purchases or balance transfers. While these offers can provide a cost-effective way to manage debt or make large purchases, beware of possible fees or the cancellation of the offer altogether for missed or late payments.

Crunching the cards

Use online tools and reviews to help narrow down your options and make a decision.

  • Compare Multiple Cards: Use comparison tools and calculators to weigh interest rates, fees, rewards and other benefits side by side.
  • Read Reviews and User Experiences: Online reviews and forums can provide insights into customer service, ease of redemption, and overall satisfaction.

The bottom line

Picking the best rewards credit card requires careful consideration of your spending habits and financial goals. By understanding the types of rewards available, evaluating redemption options, and considering additional benefits, you can maximize the value of your credit card while enjoying perks that suit your lifestyle. Remember to review your options regularly to ensure that your card continues to serve your changing needs.

Share

Roadside Assistance



    Not a member?

        Copyright ©2025 AAA Club Alliance Inc.